It's
A Living Seasons 5 is a Mixed Bag
by
Kristin Battestella
By
1987, It's A Living and
its Above the Top high rise waitresses are in full
syndication swing for Year Five – the series' longest season at
twenty-six episodes. Ironically,
the second episode “Her Back to the Future” should have been the
Season Five premiere, showing how outlandish It's
A Living can
get with hostess
Nancy Beebe (Marion Mercer) dreaming what everything would be like in
ten years. Lyle Waggoner (The
Carol Burnett Show) guests
amid
Chippendales,
an impeached president Ed Asner, and a few maracas as the waitresses
bring down the house. I almost
wish It's
A Living was
always this zany with one plot giving everyone a moment to shine.
Even the distorted, dreamy focus, spotlights, jump editing, and music
changes provide an extra comedy panache.
Certainly
“Sweet
Charity” recalls The
Golden Girls' “Henny
Penny – Straight, No Chaser” as wannabe actress Dot Higgins'
(Gail Edwards) children's theater gets sick so our waitresses act out
Little
Red Riding Hood. Both
episodes were written by producer Tom Whedon and half the time is
wasted in setting the scene, however this is a rare episode away from
the hotel restaurant. Nancy is said to be in her dressing room baying
at the moon to prepare playing the big bad wolf, and the costumes,
nerves, cardboard stage design, and silly song and dance are so
stupid, it's fun when it all goes humorously wrong. By contrast,
there's a touch of antagonism and conflicts that would actually
happen between coworkers in
“Search
and Strike” thanks to vengeful miscommunications and invasion of
privacy protests when the staff's lockers are searched. When nothing
but a cheap tawdry novel is found on naive Amy's (Crystal Bernard)
shelf, the waitresses decide to forge a diary from chef Howard
(Richard Stahl) for infatuated Nancy to find. Here It's
A Living gets
right to the point in not making it easy for our ladies. Likewise,
“The One About The Tattooed Lady” provides cranky retirees, a
funeral party bringing the urn to Above the Top, and Nancy wanting to
impress a well to do cousin who it turns out ran away to join the
circus. The ladies can't remember the late regular who has left them
$5,000, and a lot of nothing is actually happening, but the one night
at the restaurant hi-jinks provides lessons, mistaken farce, and
twists with It's
A Living firing
on all cylinders. Dot still thinks being a waitress is temporary
after nine years and gets another wannabe actress a job as a
dishwasher in “Dot's Hope.” She thinks L.A. will eat up the green
newbie, Nancy laughs at Dot's opinions, and Howard thinks a
dishwasher is a man's job and overcompensates by being super nice
even when Hope makes mistakes. Dot doesn't get the part on a big
sitcom but Hope does, and It's
A Living posits
on the conflict, jealousy, and if being a waitress is the career and
it's the dreams that become the hobby on the side.
Unfortunately,
It's A Living
relies on far too many marriage themed episodes as if there were no
other sitcom subjects. Even piano player Sonny Mann (Paul Kreppel) is
at the altar in the
“Till Death Do Us Part” premiere. No one expects the nuptials to
actually happen, and the more mature secondary plot of Howard wearing
a toupee to impress his high school girlfriend takes a backseat,
setting Year Five off on the wrong tone. Dot realizes her baby clock
is ticking in “The Date Show,” but her looking at baby books and
making a list of potential fathers is resolved in two scenes. The
seriousness of her actually having a pregnancy scare could have been
poignant, but once again It's
A Living crowds
an entry with too many plots that deserved more attention.
It's
A Living often
plays solely for the punchline, and it can be frustrating to watch
when so
many great events, ideas, and situations are merely said for
something to say rather than actually shown. Is It's
A Living merely
meant to be about that ensemble dialogue producing canned laughter or
is it just poor writing that never delves into deeper
characterizations? I like the ladies and want to see their ups and
downs in and out of the restaurant, but It's
A Living gets
tiring when the episodes do nothing but talk about things that don't
happen. Do I expect too much of the show now compared to the casual
catch an episode charm of it then? The performances carry the series,
but viewing critically shows how little the ensemble is actually
given to do, and Season Five lags mid-season with
nonstarter stories, and entwined A and B plots over-reliant on too
many visiting relatives come too many episodes in a row late in the
season. Sonny shooting a music video overtakes Ginger's visiting Nana
in “Ginger's Grandmother Show,” so we don't see the three's a
crowd scenarios with Ginger telling her she can't drive and roommate
Amy bonding with Nana. The music video itself is also embarrassing
and not
what
I had in mind when I asked for It's
A Living to
embrace it's song and dance opportunities.
Why couldn't a real guest musician rent Above the Top for a shoot?
Campaign
volunteer Ginger is caught by the newspaper on the lap of a
politician but Sonny ditching a one night stand is the priority
of “Ginger
and the Senator.” Although the resulting conflict
between all four ladies is great, everything is resolved because time
is up, and a few episodes focusing mostly on one plot without
shoehorned in Sonny moments are a marked difference. Dot singing on
an adopt-a-pet telethon also waits while Sonny uses saving a choking
patron to score in “Healings, Nothing More Than Healings,” but
her rehearsal beside the piano shames Sonny and even impresses Nancy.
It's
A Living seems
okay with never letting characters progress, preferring to be
syndication ready with no need to see anything before to tune in, and
the penultimate filler clip show “The
Waiting Game” provides uneven musical highlights for some and mere
quips for others. The framing device of a journalist interviewing the
waitress about the pros and cons of the job could have been very
interesting, for none of the ladies think of waitressing as their
primary career. It's
A Living has
no clips to show when the interviewer asks the women if
living together and working together is a conflict or reinforces
their relationships, and the staff losing their hotel parking
privileges in the season
finale is played for stereotypes rather than labor commentary. They
protest the problems women face with street parking in the wee hours,
but managements puts a television in the lounge as compensation –
because the point of the episode is the ladies becoming obsessed with
the latest juicy miniseries, not anybody standing up for themselves.
Top
billed Barrie Youngfellow's Jan Hoffmeyer Gray has spent five years
in law school but quotes legalese she said she heard on Simon
& Simon and
now knits in the lounge instead of studying.
We
never see her home life, but Jan supposedly tells her husband Richie
about what happens at work and they laugh about it when not arguing
over the double standard between her daughter not being allowed to
see Madonna while his son is free to go to The Beastie Boys concert.
Jan takes piano lessons with her step son, wanting to bond with him
and teach him some culture and disciple, yet It's
A Living doesn't
think that is an important enough plot to show. Her daughter Ellen is
now fourteen and dating an older boy in “No,
My Darling Daughter,” but again it's all more told rather than seen
and mostly about everyone except Jan. She talks about writing up a
will with Richie, and Richard Kline actually appears in “Take Back
Your Mink,” coming into a big project and splurging on the titular
frock for Jan. The girls fawn over it in great ensemble moments
properly interwoven not crowding each other, for It's
A Living is
best when focusing on its down on their luck waitresses and their
economic dilemmas. Richie's project
falls through amid a hotel blood drive gone awry, and Jan must figure
out where they can cut costs – including returning the coat. It's
A Living doesn't
forget Jan's dad dated Dot's mom when he visits again in “Daddy's
Little Girl,” but Jan invites her mom Georgann Johnson (Dr.
Quinn, Medicine Woman)
to dine with dad, who has actually married again to a younger woman.
The awkward, passive aggressive zingers and family surprises earn
most of the episode's focus, and even Jan faints. Dot suggests Jan
wear a wig to spice up her marriage in “Tune In, Tune Out,” but
Jan's upset, even jealous of herself when Richie prefers the wig. The
delicious relationship dilemma is crammed into an episode also
featuring a labor dispute when both deserved their own slots, not to
mention it's all odd because Richie calls Jan 'Red' and this episode
is strangely placed as the finale after It's
A Living's requisite
clip show. Nancy
Beebe confides in Jan and almost considers her a friend but refuses
to hug her. Marian Mercer's severe hostess kisses up to a hotel
stockholder's daughter for her wedding, and the waitresses are
suspicious when Nancy is nice. She freely lends Richard Stahl's chef
Howard the $900 he owes the loan shark, but of course, the money is
said to be under her pillow. Howard has three talents – cooking,
magic, and bowling – but he doesn't want Nancy to change him and
admits he feels smothered by her advances. Nancy
tells Howard he can knock on her door, and their relationship finally
matures from sexual harassment to a mutual goodnight kiss. The next
day regrets and workplace awkwardness could have continued for
multiple episodes as they agree to continue dating, however out of
order production and erroneous episode airings play up, reset, or
erase their romance.
He's not ready to commit and dates others, but guest
singer Jack Jones commands the restaurant crowd, puts Sonny to shame,
and whisks Nancy to Vegas in
“The
Vegas Show” two-parter. This probably didn't need to be an hour,
yet multiple storylines are fulfilled regarding maneater double
standards and mid-life fears, making the case that ongoing arc
stories would have better served It's
A Living,
but that was never going to happen in 1987. Howard flies to Vegas to
defend Nancy's honor and asks her to marry him in an excellent moment
that ends up rushed alongside other plots before a five minute
wedding with an Elvis impersonator. A
few scenes per episode in the kitchen provide hear tell of a $465
checkbook mistake because Howard is still renting his old apartment,
but
their marriage is said to be a balancing act with Nancy going to his
Chuck Norris marathon and Howard telling her to behave while at Above
the Top.
Crystal
Bernard's virginal Amy Tompkins wants five kids and a dog with the
white picket fence, but she's shocked when researching her family
tree reveals her grandmother was a madam. It's more an aside than a
major plot, and It's A
Living keeps
the character naive with pink bows and denim ruffles
like
one of the orphans on
Jem. Customers
roll their eyes at her Snyder, Texas a la St. Olaf stories, and Amy
gets obsessed with a food processor until Ginger destroys it but
sadly, we don't get to see any of their roommate struggles. The
girls have nice heart to hearts about fears and rehabilitation when
Amy's
prison pen pal visits in “A Pen Pal for Your Thoughts,” however
he's not handsome as written, just an old man who uses Amy to rob a
liquor store off screen. Too many plots are unnecessarily squashed
together while Bernard goes underutilized amid the preposterous
pairing of Amy and Sonny's sleazy friend Louie in “The Amy and
Louie Show.” Not only do we not get to see Howard buying a boxer
(just like on The
Golden Girls)
and Nancy getting into the gym scene, Amy's awkward bowling date is
ultimately about Sonny making Louie choose between them.
Most
of Gail Edwards' Dot Higgins' acting shenanigans are likewise off
screen or a phone call rejection from her latest audition. She wants
to be a star but can't afford a new $30,000 car unless she sleeps in
it. Dot
says she enjoys suppressing her personality to create another
character and tries wearing a blonde wig – afterthoughts in the
restaurant lounge when we should have seen an episode revolving
around her dieting to the extreme for an anorexic role. Dot begins to
feel grotesque at serving all the food she can't eat, but it's all a
subplot resolved in a few scenes. When Dot lands a soap opera role in
“The Killing of Sister Dot,” the episode is largely about Amy
and Ginger arguing over planning a party and Howard's nomination for
a chef award. Coming after several one plot episodes, this entry
proves how the ABC plotting does not work for It's
A Living. Dot's
playing a nun killed in a
tabernacle explosion before also playing her evil twin, but it's all
talk rather than us laughing at the show within a shown. It's
delightful when the girls play dress up and rehearse in the lounge,
and this ludicrous soap could have been a great ongoing in joke.
Likewise, “Strictly Personal” is about everything but Dot's
posting in the personals column. She chooses against a millionaire
with a yacht and instead ends up with the boy who runs Pecos Pete's
Chow Wagon on The
Golden Girls.
Dot does get a decent newspaper boyfriend in “Everyone's a Critic,”
but he has to review her new play when we, of course,
don't
get to see how enthusiastically bad her performance was.
Confident
Sheryl Lee Ralph as Ginger St. James intends to run her own fashion
business with style and efficiency and enjoys getting back at Nancy.
Her steady Jason names his boat after her but she's too stylish to
get wet and we don't get to see their sailing mishaps anyway. I'd
like to have seen her waiting tables go awry when she gets some crazy
sculpted nails and can't open her locker with them, but alas, most of
Ginger's excitement is again off camera. She dresses up Amy and is
unusually fearful when meeting Jason's parents – until they are
glad to see her after roommate Amy is the one to answer the door.
It's disappointing It's A
Living doesn't
maximize Ralph or the character; we don't even find out her name is
actually Virginia until late in Year Five. Of
course, Ginger rejects Jason's pushy proposal in “The No Guys
Show,” but It's
A Living forgot
that her not being ready to get married also happened near the end of
Season Four. Amy gossips to the other girls about Ginger and Jason's
ups and downs, cheaply creating backhanded developments we never saw
when Phil Morris' (Seinfeld)
Jason should have been a recurring character. Instead, we see Ginger
dumping him on the phone in the lounge before she calls to take him
up again, and it's all a stagnant,
unfair nothing burger despite most of the episode focusing on this
story – an engagement that's also strung along through most of
Season Six. Unfortunately,
Paul Kreppel's piano gags as Sonny Mann also waste precious time It's
A Living did
not have. He butchers the national anthem, scabs when his union goes
on strike, and is angry when a fat girl he expects to be easy isn't.
Sonny takes
an art class for the nude models and wants the girls to sign up so he
can finger paint, and he's surprised when his sex book gets rejected
by the publisher for his suggestion that a man should start a date
with beer and knock out drops. WTF. Sonny thinks sleeping with Amy
would make him feel better because his mother berates him in “The
Sonny's Mother Show.” She's right that when he acts like a man, he
will be treated like one, but rather than any lessons learned, we
instead get a Sonny as a kid flashback featuring Dustin Diamond
(Saved
by the Bell). When
a women's feminist group comes to Above the Top in “Twelve Angry
Women,” Sonny deserves every insult they give him for his touch
feely and inappropriate songs. They point out how the girls are
overworked and underpaid and harassed in their uniforms, but this
episode is about Sonny instead. It was enough to stall my re-watch
mid-season, and just once I wish there was an episode without Sonny.
I don't remember if he was so popular back then, but his antics are
insufferable now and I can't fathom why so many plots revolve around
him while the waitresses remain largely unexplored.
The
swinging theme tune and ritzy opening credits once again set the It's
A Living mood
even if some episodes are too short at under twenty-one minutes with
credits. The black and burgundy uniforms are classy now, but the
teased hair in big banana clips rise to the height of eighties
deliciousness amid colorful ruffles and high-waisted acid wash jeans.
The wedding gowns, however, are hideous, and poor Nancy
wears terrible draped gowns with baggy shirts, dropped waists, and
giant belts. Late in the season she wears a
green ensemble that looks more 1890s than 1980s, but the exaggerate
sleeves and ruffled train are actually the best she's worn. The
menswear bow tie frocks unfortunately look like cast offs from
Dorothy Zbornak's closet. It's
A Living borrows
incidental music from The
Golden Girls as
well – they go to the same reused chapel set, and there are so many
guests from The
Golden Girls making
appearances on It's A
Living it's
almost comical. Honestly, if you are a massive fan of The Golden Girls, it
becomes almost impossible to separate re-watching the lesser seen
It's A Living from
it's beloved
sister production.
Currently,
It's A Living finally
has multiple seasons available on several FAST platforms. However,
some of the episodes seem mislabeled or out of order, and either by
oversight or a deliberate pull, the Season Five episode
“Skin Deep” is not available. I started reviewing this series
with a full length, episodic focus because I wanted to bring
attention to a forgotten show I enjoyed. However, Year Five felt like
a chore with few stand out episodes because the production's goal
seems to be going through motions for syndication ease while yes of
course The
Golden Girls received
all the attention. It's
A Living had
the potential to be as great – if their own writers would have paid
attention to the ensemble storytelling.