Appaloosa
A Quiet, Character Western
by
Kristin Battestella
Co-writer,
director, and producer Ed Harris (Pollock)
also stars in the 2008 western Appaloosa.
Based
on the Robert B. Parker
(Spencer for Hire)
novel, this quiet character piece invokes a nostalgic, sophisticated
atmosphere with period detail and fine performances.
It's
the New Mexico Territory, 1882 and the town of Appaloosa calls in
peacekeeper Virgil Cole (Harris) and his deputy Everett Hitch (Viggo
Mortensen) to bring in murderous, power hungry rancher Randall Bragg
(Jeremy Irons). Cole's reputation for the law proceeds him, however
neither he nor his deputy know how to handle the affections of widow
Allie French (Renee Zellweger) – much less interference of hired
gun Ring Shelton (Lance Henriksen) amid train raids, corrupt trials,
Chiricahua standoffs, and betrayed alliances.
Quick
shootouts are the real law here, immediately setting the reckless
tense as the narration tells of bitter soldiers post War between the
States choosing sides in The West. Viewers must pay attention to the
dialogue, for information happens fast amid the sophisticated
conversations and legalese agreements. Despite rugged airs as enemies
sit down at opposite sides of the table to share a whiskey, there's a
civilized code of honor to the violence – chit chat on the law
versus the outlaw as two sides of the same coin. Dual
layers, rivalries, and subtle jealousy keep this character piece
classy rather than embellishing the drama with try hard cool.
However, Appaloosa
gives
our gents enough cowboy fun even if the buddy moments, verbal spars,
and chuckles have a certain gravitas.
Tender scenes between the fisticuffs don't hit the audience over the
head with scandal, and good or bad, everybody wears black hats. The
raids at dawn, jailbreak vigils, circuit judge, and sheriff escorts
are common to the genre – Appaloosa
feels
similar to a lot of John Wayne or Richard Widmark pictures – but
this isn't a knock off
or spoof playing into the western winks. Appaloosa
is
also not a slow piece,
however the film making itself may be pleasingly perceived as quiet.
Players converse in reasonable length scenes, polite two-shots let
the cast be, and no noticeable editing intrudes on the debate. Where
today's movies often over rely on physical action replacing plot
progression, here conflict happens with introspective character
movement rather than crescendos. Dangerous bridges, abductions, and
nail-biting negotiations are done in camera without zooms or
bombastic antics. Personal and professional love triangles collide
via the symbolic framework of an unfinished house, and horseback
pursuits ride on alongside standoffs and treachery as enemies must
work together before the final shootout.
Gruff
in his beard Viggo Mortensen's (Eastern Promises) Everett Hitch may
have quit his West Point commission but he's still never without his
eight gauge shotgun. He may follow Virgil Cole, finish the shootout,
pull him off in a fight, or back him up whichever hot or cold is
required, yet the lawmen seem more like an equal pair rather than
marshal in charge and obeying deputy. Townsfolk prefer discussing
their predicament with the more amicable Hitch, and he's silently
barters with a Chiricahua raiding party. Despite any bust ups on the
case, he apologizes for Virgil's sandpaper ways because he gets the
job done. Hitch refuses to debate whether he's a better gunslinger
since Virgil is the undisputed best, but Cole says it's Hitch's
emotions that keep him from the top. What will it take for him to
step out of Virgil's shadow?Audiences today aren't used to seeing men
talk about their sensitivity onscreen, but lawmen catching feelings
can only lead to trouble and the emotion is a dynamic change of pace.
Although Hitch chooses to be second fiddle, several critical scenes
are from his point of view, and his larger than life shotgun
posturing is often the center of the frame – visually, he is the
true star of Appaloosa in
the unspoken spirit of The
Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.
Of course, black hat suave Ed Harris as Virgil Cole insists town
leaders sign his way into law and warns victims he is a fast draw but
will pistol whip a cowboy to get answers. Virgil's a cold killer but
doesn't like a lady teasing him about being socially awkward. He's
not well spoken and has a poor vocabulary but educates himself. While
Cole is not without compassion, apologizes when warranted, and
insists on being straight with Hitch; he's unaccustomed to the
personal interfering with the professional, refusing to think about
anything else until their quarry's caught. Can Cole give up his
stubborn marshaling and idly retire in Appaloosa? Though not intended
as homosexual, there is a deep, comforting trust between these
characters – an inseparable bat man relationship with humor and
caring a woman can't understand. Unfortunately, Virgil's blind to any
jealously and needs Hitch's aide thanks to the hitherto unknown
domestic.
Renee
Zellweger (Chicago)
as piano playing widow Allie French, however, has the men looking
twice as she talks sassy and makes Cole blush. She wants to be with
him but dislikes how his work will always be first. Allie doesn't
want to be a part of his profession – especially when her life is
at risk – and thus turns her flirtations toward the equally
besotted Hitch. She's wise to the two men competing even if they
don't seem to really know women at all. Hitch insists they are both
“with Virgil” and not “with each other,” unaware of the
deliberate game she is playing. Allie is not a foolish lady and does
what she has to do. A woman in this era must stick with the nearest
man to survive, and the higher the man, the better. Such pretty is
going to be problematic, and Allie resents how a woman can't be the
real boss outside of playing house. Although the character is meant
to be wishy washy, the portrayal is too uneven and falls flat amid
the stronger leads. Allie comes between the men because the plot says
so, not because she is really going toe to toe with them in a shrewd,
feminine game of chess. Despite unanswered questions about her, the
character is unlikable rather than mysterious and there's no reason
to care about her mixed motivations. The name Bragg, however, fits
Jeremy Irons' (High Rise)
power hungry rancher. He contests the lawmen at every turn, teasing
Virgil about reading Emerson while gloating about their at odds
social standing and his friends in high places. The one on ones are
great when we get them, but Bragg needed a little more to do than
bookend the piece with his crimes and swindles. There's no real
reason why he goes from rancher to sheriff killer – refusing to
surrender his rapist work hands doesn't create villainous dimension.
There's more to his and the town story in the deleted scenes and
behind the scenes discussions on the Appaloosa
blu-ray set, but in a western, the bad guy just has to be the bad
guy, so any added class from Irons is a bonus. Likewise, there should
have been more to gun for hire Lance Henriksen (Near Dark). He's
willing to fight at the Chiricahua raid or hold up a train – but
the price influences which side he defends.
Ranch
emblems, wooden buildings, and traditional western front architecture
establish Appaloosa's
Old West atmosphere along with numerous gun belts and cowboy hats.
Desert vistas and mountainous scenery make those on horseback tiny on
the dusty frontier while contrasting Victorian décor, wallpaper, oil
lamps, and tea sets keep the interiors civilized. Carriages,
outhouses, and saloon doors complete the expected western style yet
Appaloosa remains
colorful and bright without the commonly associated fifties pink or
mid-century garish design. The muted look and old fashioned patina,
however, is not so modern bleak, dark, and grainy that viewers can't
see the nighttime action. The gunshots are also
not outrageously loud, preferring a more natural pop and the
resounding thud when a man drops. It's a surprising natural choice
that makes the gun violence more ruthless, for these shootouts aren't
rad cool action scenes but a fast draw where the killer doesn't bat
an eye. Precious little language, nudity, brief horse injuries, and
blood likewise refuse to bow to sensationalism. Instead Appaloosa
has
an amazing attention to
detail with vintage costuming and period trains. Choice music is only
used for otherwise quiet scenes and riding transitions, adding to the
lawless beauty with guitar strings and Spanish motifs. Appaloosa
is
impressive for its mere twenty million dollar budget, again
questioning why such mid-sized pictures have fallen out of Hollywood
favor.
While
underwhelming to some who think nothing but too much talking is
happening, Appaloosa has
an audience in fans of the cast and viewers seeking quality westerns.
Granted, the plot could have been more well rounded between the law
and the villains. This won't be a gritty two hours as some expect nor
have enough lighthearted moments for others. Appaloosa
is more about the character relationships and takes several viewings
to pick up all the subtle dynamics. The straightforward story of
buddy marshals versus bad guys and a woman coming between them
provides enough layered nuances. Compared to the recent The
Magnificent Seven remake
that has all the extra bells and whistles yet felt lacking, Appaloosa
has
personality, quirks, and man versus man, man versus nature, and man
versus himself conflict that better states the unspoken man's man
without all the in your face. There
are sequels to the source novel – today this would be a television
series for sure – but I'd love to see this stock company continue
doing more western character pieces. Appaloosa
has
a charming cast,
location, and style with both western motifs of old as well as
maturity and a modern sophistication worth a look.